Mad men or sad men?

Posted in General, Advertising, Branwell Johnson, Latest reporters' blogs March 4th, 2008 by Branwell Johnson

BBC Four’s new drama series on 60s advertising, Mad Men, did what it said it would on the tin – but is that exciting and engaging enough? Not in my book, I won’t be returning to the trials and tribulations of Madison Avenue.

The show itself was pretty dull – if the plot is going to be driven by trying to win a pitch each week that’s not very gripping. The characters are all unlikeable – not a drawback considering this is from the pen of a Sopranos writer, but the people paraded so far are not even warm, witty or that interesting.

There is no-one to act as a moral compass, a la Jack in Lost, or even act heroically. Funny, isn’t it, how very profession, from doctors to lawyers, tries to self-mythologise and imagine itself as some kind of swaggering, warrior tribe or lords of the universe. If Mad Men is subtly pricking this balloon of pretension then that’s interesting, if not, then it’s tediously adding to the pile of fetishised fools that includes Frank and the Rat Pack and East End gangsters.

On the back o the show plenty of nostalgia buffs and old timers are lauding the 60s as the perfect time to work in advertising. Looked pretty dull to me. What the heck did they do with their time apart from drink themselves in to oblivion? With so few media channels to exploit boredom must’ve set in by, oh, 10.30 am? It seems a far more exciting time now with more challenges to stretch the grey matter, more interesting people from so many different areas of communication to work with and a greater sense of achievement.

And don’t worry, there is still plenty of drinking and philandering (or so I hear) going on within Soho’s square mile, if not outside, if that’s what floats your boat. Anyone going to do a  soft sell for Mad Men to me?

del.icio.usTechnorati

Comments (3)

RedCreative’s comment is....

Add comment
Back to top

Slowly, slowly catchee monley I think.
I reckon it will take about 3 or 4 episodes for the viewed to make a decision; characters will have revealed their substance, and the plot and sub-plots will being in to reveal themselves.
I am far from a fan of big bucks American TV, (Lost an exception), but am intrigued so far.
Amazing how politically incorrect that period was! Different genre, but BBC’s Life on Mars (a period which I was around in), brings it all back, just how ‘wrong’ it was then!

Melinda Varley’s comment is....

Add comment
Back to top

Apart from the fact I have a crush on the creative director, I thought the show was a good insight to adland back in the day, and I am hoping it will depict how advertising has evolved - such as the moral dilemma of advertising cigarettes.
Also I think its interesting to see the industry working on typewriters, hand-drawn poster campaigns and coupons in the newspaper. If nothing else, the show will make you not just appreciate how far the industry has come, but its place in the economy.

Hayes Thompson’s comment is....

Add comment
Back to top

Are you just annoyed because the series uses the same word as Mad.co.uk?

You ask, ‘why?’ I say, ‘why not?’

You’re in the game. This is a series about the game. Give it a chance.

Watch a few more episodes, then decide. Admire the sets. Oggle the women. Fantasize about being able to smoke a fag. Enjoy the slow pace - just the antidote for today’s media crackheads and their need for their next edit/cut fix every one second.

I can’t even remember his name but I’m waiting for the young upstart’s next move. Getting married on Sunday, visiting the new girl he insulted in the office on Friday night for a bit of action. Her accepting! Filthmongers.

If you’re looking for a moral compass, I think you’re probably watching the wrong show. Isn’t that one of the points?

Your comment is....

You must be logged in to post a comment.

madcomments encourages comments to be short and to the point. Comments should show a courteous regard for the presence of other voices in the discussion. We reserve the right to edit or delete comments that do not adhere to this standard.

Archives